Deportation, denaturalisation, ending birthright citizenship: How Trump’s plans could spell havoc

They risk permanently destabilising immigrant communities that fuel significant sectors of the US economy and straining family and social ties.

Deportation, denaturalisation, ending birthright citizenship: How Trump’s plans could spell havoc

Join our WhatsApp Community to receive travel deals, free stays, and special offers!
- Join Now -

Join our WhatsApp Community to receive travel deals, free stays, and special offers!
- Join Now -

The immigration debate has long shaped political agendas in the US and Europe, often escalating in times of social or economic uncertainty. In the US election, a tough-on-immigration stance from president-elect Donald Trump, including promises of mass deportations, appears to have resonated with voters.

History shows that these policies may have initial public support, but raise other issues when executed. President Dwight D Eisenhower’s 1954 Operation Wetback deported over 1 million Mexican nationals, blending fear-based public messaging with large-scale enforcement.

Despite its devastating impact on thousands of families, including many US citizens of Mexican heritage, the programme faced backlash. It was extremely costly and logistically difficult, and ultimately did little to stop irregular migration from Mexico. Many of those who were deported returned to the US soon after.

Fast forward to the Trump era, where promises of a “impenetrable, physical, tall, powerful, beautiful, southern border wall” and more deportations in 2016 tapped into similar populist views.

Now, in 2024, Trump has doubled down with “Operation Aurora” pledging even tougher immigration enforcement measures.

Rhetoric and reality

Looking past the bombastic electoral rhetoric, deportation campaigns face significant hurdles. In addition to financial cost, any programme is likely to face public opposition and legal challenges.

The government will need cooperation from migrants’ home countries and transit nations (which is hard to obtain), and diplomatic...

Read more